NVR Logo
Father sues over teen drowning
Labor Day 2007 tragedy at Berryessa draws civil suit
Thursday, October 16, 2008
Save and Share Share
The father of a teen whose blood alcohol level was .17 percent when she drowned at Lake Berryessa has filed a wrongful death suit against the girl’s mother and several others who were present at the Labor Day 2007 outing.

Troy Brookman, the biological father of 13-year-old Erin Brookman, filed a civil lawsuit in Napa County courts against the girl’s mother, Susan Jones, and four other people who were with the teen on the day she died of the combined effects of alcohol and carbon monoxide poisoning caused by boat engine fumes.
Others named in the lawsuit are Deborah Ferolito, Robert Hansel, Donovan Burgess and Eric Persson.

According to the lawsuit, Ferolito owned the “party barge where she and Hansel consumed significant amounts of alcohol and permitted several minors, including Erin Brookman, to also consume significant amounts of alcohol both at the campsite and on the boat.”
Erin Brookman was at the lake with family and friends who gathered on several boats near the Pope Creek Bridge. She and a female friend were in the water on the swimming platform on the rear of Ferolito’s boat. They were not wearing life jackets, according to the lawsuit. They went to another ski boat owned by Eric Persson, which according to the lawsuit had its engine idling so they could listen to music on their stereos.

The lawsuit claims that Erin Brookman and her friend went to Persson’s boat and held onto the wooden step at the back of his boat for several minutes.
Brookman’s friend became sick from the exhaust fumes and climbed into boat, according to the lawsuit, adding, while attending to her, Brookman also became ill from the exhaust fumes and slipped under the water.

A search for Brookman was unsuccessful and her body was found the next day, which would have been her 14th birthday.

Troy Brookman’s attorney, John Demas of Sacramento, said the lawsuit focuses mainly on the dangers of leaving boat motors running when swimmers are in close proximity.

“A law was passed this past year prohibiting boat owners from running their motors when boats are moored or not moving. We want to get the word out that this is a very dangerous situation which in this case caused a young girl to lose her life,” Demas said.

Demas said although alcohol was a factor in Brookman’s death, the carbon monoxide poisoning was enough to cause the teen to die.

Napa County Sheriff’s Capt. Jean Donaldson said the criminal investigation into Brookman’s death is closed.

“Our investigation was reviewed by the district attorney’s office and they felt there was not enough evidence to file criminal charges,” Donaldson said. “There were allegations that adults provided alcohol to the minors, but we did not find any evidence to substantiate those allegations.”
22 comment(s)

Skeptically Watching wrote on Oct 16, 2008 6:07 AM:

" Jean:

Just because Sheriff's investigators couldn't come up with any evidence minors were being supplied with alcohol by adults, doesn't mean it didn't happen. She came there with adults, was in the presence of adults when she died, and had a .17 BAC. If it walks like a duck and talks like a duck...it's probalby a duck. These adults, including her mother, should be held fully responsible for this child's death. "

napathoughts wrote on Oct 16, 2008 7:25 AM:

" Everyone is looking for a payday, how sad. "

LocalNapa wrote on Oct 16, 2008 8:51 AM:

" napathoughts: It's called accountability, not a payday, for a tragic event that could have been avoided with responsible parenting. "

napabicycler wrote on Oct 16, 2008 9:08 AM:

" I don’t believe it’s about a payday, I believe it’s about accountability, which is sorely lacking in our society today. "

Paddy wrote on Oct 16, 2008 9:16 AM:

" I'm one of the last people to condone litigation but in this case I would have to agree with this suit being introduced. It appears a lot of adults made some very poor decisions and should have to face the severe consequences. If nothing else, their names are out there in public. This is tragic and sad for a number of reasons. "

cordell wrote on Oct 16, 2008 9:53 AM:

" The responsible parties should be prosecuted. Nobody should be making money off of this tragedy. "

mafi wrote on Oct 16, 2008 12:07 PM:

" I doubt any of the involved adults would admit providing the alcohol, so the DA can't prove the case. A civil suit is sad, but the names are out and maybe the father will use the money to promote safety, scholarships in his daughters name, etc.. "

Froggie1559 wrote on Oct 16, 2008 2:13 PM:

" The adults should absolutely be held liable, either criminally or otherwise, for the death of this girl. How tragic! Talk about adults setting bad examples for the kids! Why is it often the innocent who pay the price? "

opiniagirl wrote on Oct 16, 2008 2:24 PM:

" This father will deprived of his lovely daughter for the REST OF HIS LIFE.

Who is anyone to say what he should do in response. A messasge must be sent to adults that contribute to dangerous behavior, even if it is a parent.

I am wondering why there isn't a negligence charge agains mom - who was present and could have easily prevented the childs alcohol consumption is it was truly unauthorized. .17 is twice the legal limit, how could anyone not recognize an impaired "drunk" child. Someone must have noticed and nobody DID anything...it was mom's job to notice, since she was the adult in charge of her own child.

If this situation had been different and the child stole a car and ran over someone, the book would have been thrown at the adults present...but since she only killed herself...we let it slide? "

707jng wrote on Oct 16, 2008 3:28 PM:

" None of us know for sure that these girls were given alcohol by adults. Unless you were there, how do you know that these teenagers didn't steal the alcohol??? I remember being 13 and doing things like this all the time. There's always 2 sides to every story and every post here assumes that they know what happened...
If I were this father I would probably do the same thing he is. Maybe this is his way of finding closure because it couldn't be proved that the adults gave these kids alcohol... "

opiniagirl wrote on Oct 16, 2008 4:00 PM:

" Sorry for what is pretty much the worst spelling in the world! (above) I was in a hurry, lol! "

Annabella wrote on Oct 16, 2008 4:29 PM:

" The "biological father?" Humm, well now that about says it. "

opiniagirl wrote on Oct 16, 2008 4:44 PM:

" Annabella:

You're not suggesting that this father has limited rights because he is listed as "biological", which sometimes indicates absent or uninvolved, though not always...

Even if he was, although it would have been VERY unfotunate for him, this does not mean that he would not have been a great father in the future given the chance.

My Bio dad ran around on my mom, divorced her, never saw us, ran away from child support, offerred his teens pot, married 4 other women in a row, and partied until I was about 22. Now he is settled in a wonderful solid marraige and is a phenominal husband father and grandfather.

This dad will never have that chance with his daughter!

That says it all! "

Napa7192 wrote on Oct 16, 2008 6:57 PM:

" Well said opiniagirl... "

Annabella wrote on Oct 16, 2008 8:19 PM:

" Well...you are all so liberal. Yes you are correct in assuming that Biological is synonomous with absent and uninvolved. Exactly what came to mind. We have a whole generation and then some of biologicals of which most are absent and uninvolved. Somehow some of them become involved when it suits them. It's nice you can be so forgiving. I wonder if your mother shares in this. This is a sad and unfortunate story...but it was the biological father who is filing the suit...against her own mother which indicates by the suit that she was and unfit mother but okay he was unwilling to be the girls legitimate father. Anyway I read it...it's about $$$$. "

opiniagirl wrote on Oct 17, 2008 11:13 AM:

" LOL - That is the first time in my life I have been called liberal, haha.

No not liberal, just human and open to forgiveness and change. Compassion is what seperates us from the apes!

My mother and bio dad are both happily remarried and they still speak to eachother with respect and loving kindness, we even celebrate holidays as 1 large family. My mother holds no bitterness against him, which says oodles about her as a strong Christian woman.

No amount of money in the world can replace what this father lost, but it can ease the pain and send a strong messsage. If he truly was an absent father, he will carry that burden for the rest of his life whether he drives it around in a pinto or a Mercedes.

My best friends "biological" dad was a wonderful father and her stepdad was horrific! So when used for clarification "biological" may not always be what you think.

We don't know if he was unwilling to be the girls father, I have not seen that issue addressed to the public other than "biological", which could simply be an adjective for clarification purposes.

You know that saying about when you assume.... "

amazed wrote on Oct 17, 2008 12:49 PM:

" Hmm, if the suit is only to point out the dangers of leaving the boat engine idling, why isn't that boat owner, Eric Persson, the only one sued? Clearly, the dad is furious at the mom because her negligence, and possibly the negligence of her party friends, cost their child her life. Why not call it what it is, and drop the attorney mumbo-jumbo? "

LakeGirl wrote on Oct 17, 2008 1:29 PM:

" I was there that day, and it sad. First off, the bridge has NEVER been a place for kids, and the parents should have known that when they went there. I find it kind of sad that a person who wasn't part of their group (Eric Persson) and was there with other ADULTS became involved because Erin swam to his boat uninvited when she was already drunk. The majority of the fault should be directed to the mother. It was not against the law to have boats on, but I know that MANY have learned about the dangers now. "

cellsitegod wrote on Oct 24, 2008 6:23 AM:

" It is about the money now. Unless the father plans on donating the money to teen alcohol abuse.
Shame on the father capitalizing on it.
The mother knows she is responsible for her daughters death regardless of being charged.
By sueing here her in court proves nothing. Other than proving the father is out to make a buck! "

james10000 wrote on Nov 15, 2008 2:37 PM:

" I'm not too sure why the Biological was used, this paper made several mistakes on Erin's death story and it may just be bad writing. Troy was her dad and in her life 100%, he fought to keep both his Daughters and lost thanks to the "give kids to the Mother" standard. He charished both is daughters. I don't feel this a money issue, as some have said, I think it's more getting a guilty verdict on those responsible. If the criminal justice system fails you there are two options, be a Vigilante and punish those responsible or a lawsuit. I ask myself whats worse, showing little care of your childs saftey that leads to death or murder. "

drowningkarma wrote on Nov 21, 2008 11:56 AM:

" I am so glad to hear that this father may get some compensation for the loss of his young daughter. I can't believe these people weren't criminally charged but hey, look at OJ Simpson!
I hope this dad gets justice through making these criminals pay monetarily. They must have some money if they were boat owners. I don't know how the 13 year old victim's mother lives with herself knowing that if she had kept a better eye on her daughter and not let her drink alcohol she would still be here today. This story is just tragic all the way around.... "

parent wrote on Nov 26, 2008 9:13 PM:

" I have read all of the comments posted and we all want to jump on the band wagon that the father is in name only, or it is all about the money. What about our responsibility as adults and parents to keep our children safe. We teach our children that they must be responsible for their action, but us as adults can walk away from ours, what message are we sending to the youth of today. Educate your children and KEEP THEM SAFE and out of Harms way. Sometimes the only way to get our message out is we must sue someone-Maybe if you are in the wrong you need to step up and take the blame. "

Comment Guidelines
The goal of the story comments section at NapaValleyRegister.com is to have an open, thought-provoking, civil community forum for all issues.
What gets your comment posted?
• Staying on topic
• Keeping your comment to 300 words or less
• Avoiding name-calling
• Addressing your comments to the message rather than the messenger
What gets your comment deleted?
• Personal attacks
• Derogatory remarks
• Name-calling of any sort
• Going off-topic
• Hate speech
• Racially-insensitive comments
• Implying guilt of a subject in a crime story before there is a court verdict
• Posting e-mail addresses
• Posting comments of a commercial nature
• POSTING WITH ALL CAPITAL LETTERS
• Linking multiple comments together with "to be continued..." to get around the 300 word limit.
The fine print
- Comments are either approved or denied. We do not edit comments.
- You are welcome to modify and resubmit a denied comment.
- Comments may take several hours to be posted.
- Comments posted are those of the writer, and do not necessarily reflect the opinion of NapaValleyRegister.com, its employees or its parent company.
- Do you have information on a story? Please go to our virtual newsroom to send us a news tip.
- If you feel a posted comment has violated our guidelines, please contact online@napanews.com or add a comment indicating you have an issue and our moderators will review the comment in question.
Search:
Web Search Powered
By Yahoo! Search
Napa Valley Register on Facebook
Copyright © 2009 Napa Valley Publishing, a member of Lee Enterprises, Inc.
Terms of Use | Privacy Policy