‘No on B’ is not a ‘no’ on resorts

2012-10-11T00:00:00Z ‘No on B’ is not a ‘no’ on resorts Napa Valley Register
October 11, 2012 12:00 am

“No on B” means “renegotiate a better deal with Silver Rose,” as our Planning Commission recommended, many of our citizens agreed, but our City Council overruled.

Let’s see what it would mean: Study all five resorts being proposed for our tiny community. Weigh their combined potential impact on traffic and vital services; don’t approve them piecemeal. Others are mega-sized Enchanted Resorts, Indian Springs, the event/conference center (at former Gliderport), and Bounsall Winery’s 80,000-square-foot multi-building.

Don’t polarize this issue, portraying those who say “No on B” as cranks wanting to return to a mythical, idyllic past. Stop scaring folks into thinking our city services will collapse if we don’t cave in and approve these large-scale expansions and developments. Scaled-down versions of Silver Rose and the other resorts will still bring essential revenues without leaving a legacy of high-density projects that clog our downtown and its entrances and overburden our public services.

Growth in the form of attractive resorts can be a true winner, but it must be responsibly regulated. Solage is a thoughtfully negotiated project that has enhanced Calistoga and has contributed significantly more dollars to our low-income housing than either Silver Rose or Enchanted Resorts has proposed.

Developers won’t make significant concessions up front. Our city leaders must tell them what we need to maintain the small-town charm that draws visitors to our area.

A good first step is for our City Council to cooperate with our Planning Commission and concerned citizens on General Plan guidelines for land use, community character and open space. A “no” vote on Measure B would give Calistoga an eleventh-hour chance at a win-win solution for all.

Sanna Craig / Calistoga

Copyright 2015 Napa Valley Register. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

(1) Comments

  1. gidlish
    Report Abuse
    gidlish - October 15, 2012 12:30 pm
    yes on resorts
    YES ON "B"
    it's called moving ahead and being proud of a new and cleaned up town that can afford to turn on the lights of city hall.
Add Comment
You must Login to comment.

Click here to get an account it's free and quick