Phillips struggles to save its charter status

Former principal to return in July
2013-05-12T19:15:00Z 2013-05-31T19:08:05Z Phillips struggles to save its charter statusISABELLE DILLS Napa Valley Register
May 12, 2013 7:15 pm  • 

Students, parents and teachers from Phillips Charter School filled the room at a recent school board meeting in an attempt to save Phillips from losing its charter.

School district administrators have said that a charter renewal for the Napa elementary school cannot be granted unless the school’s leaders come up with a viable plan to improve student test scores.

Amidst its struggles, Phillips is also undergoing a transition in leadership. The school’s current principal, Theressa Manzanedo, is being replaced by former Phillips principal Matt Manning.

Manning officially starts the job in July, but has already begun working with the school’s charter renewal committee.

The Napa Valley Unified School District has never revoked a charter, but the district has denied initial petitions to start a charter, said Maren Rocca-Hunt, director of elementary education.

Phillips submitted a draft in March proposing to adopt a curriculum based on STEM (science, technology, engineering, and math), but administrators say the timeline to implement the new program would take too long, and that Phillips needs to have a stronger focus on its English-learning students.

The school’s proposal includes taking three years to design and develop STEM instruction, and students have already fallen behind academically, Rocca-Hunt said.

“Phillips Charter School has hardworking teachers and staff. However, their instructional design needs a more concentrated focus on early literacy,” Superintendent Patrick Sweeney said.

At the May 2 board meeting, every seat in the room was filled for the school’s public hearing. With no available chairs, the youngest students in the crowd sat cross-legged on the floor.

Several of the audience members approached the podium to share their personal stories and experiences with Phillips. All spoke highly of the programs offered there and the dedication of its teachers and staff.

One of the school’s current sixth-graders ended his comments with a plea to the board of trustees: “Please keep our school the way it is.”

Charter schools are public schools that have been authorized by the district’s Board of Trustees to provide a unique curriculum described in a charter agreement. All charter schools have their own governing body but remain ultimately accountable to the district’s board.

Under state law, charter school agreements are up for renewal every five years, and schools must meet several areas of criteria in order to get approved.

Each of the trustees expressed appreciation for the comments and the outpouring of support for Phillips, but all of the trustees shared concerns that the school is falling short of expectations.

“What it comes to is looking at the facts,” trustee Robb Felder said.

One of the main concerns is that students aren’t improving academically. The test scores at Phillips Charter School have leveled off, and the school ranks poorly compared to schools with similar demographics.

Eighty-five percent of Phillips’ students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, and another 43 percent are English learners, according to the California Department of Education. Based on the results of last year’s standardized tests, Phillips earned an Academic Performance Index score of 744. Schools with similar demographics across the state earned a median API score of 800.

“It’s not a question of dedication or passion or working harder,” Felder said. “It’s about working differently.”

Considering the demographics, trustee Thomas Kensok suggested that Phillips consider a bilingual education program — similar to the Napa Valley Language Academy, whose charter was renewed during the same board meeting as Phillips’ public hearing.

Phillips and NVLA are two of the four charter schools in the Napa Valley Unified School District. The other two are Shearer Charter School and Stone Bridge School.

The board of trustees is expected to make a final decision on Phillips’ charter renewal on May 30.

Sweeney said that no matter what the board decides, the district will work to help the struggling school.

“We will continue to work closely with the teachers and staff,” Sweeney said. “Whether it is a charter or not, they are part of the district's team and student success is our goal. All students need to be ready for college and careers in the 21st century.”

Copyright 2016 Napa Valley Register. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

(4) Comments

  1. publiusa
    Report Abuse
    publiusa - May 13, 2013 12:17 pm
    I applaud the district trustees for finally getting tough with these schools with dismally low test scores. The principals and teachers are the adults at the school and they are apparently not teaching because the students are not learning. These test scores are an embarrassment to this community and a tragedy for the students. The principal and the teachers must be removed...not re assigned...because they are obviously not needed in any other position in this district if their school is failing.
  2. longtimeresident
    Report Abuse
    longtimeresident - May 13, 2013 3:14 pm
    I trust the School Board will act in a proactive manner to help Phillips reach its goals not only for the district/state mandates, but most importantly for the future of the students and their community. The conundrum is our state testing is not gauging the 21st century skills that are students are being taught so that will be marketable and competitive in what is now a global market of jobs. So for anyone to sit back and point a finger at teachers and administrators, I suggest they take a step back and ask themselves “What can I do to help this school?” We are no longer in the era of “Reading and Writing and ‘Rithmetic'”, we’re in a whirlwind of technological and global change that morphs by the hour. Information is instantaneous world-wide, but we are still trying to measure 1+1 is 2. I can’t change how our government thinks, but I can have a strong influence on helping our students succeed by leaps and bounds. We're all part of the same village, what role are you going to play?
  3. alucawanza
    Report Abuse
    alucawanza - May 13, 2013 4:08 pm
    Village teacher basher...
  4. publiusa
    Report Abuse
    publiusa - May 13, 2013 9:35 pm
    To longtimeresident: What can I do for our schools??? How about $300,000,000 we have given them in school bonds in the last 10 years. And, that money was promised to upgrade technology to the 21st century. Where did the money go?? How about the school budgets that quintupled during the past 15 years? Where did that money go?? I know, to excessive teacher and administrator salaries and benefits. And, if we can't point the finger at teachers and administrators who do we criticize???...the poor kids who are losing out? There is no whirl wind of technology...the problem is that the ancient and incompetent teachers could be taught technology by their students. I agree that we are all part of the same village, but we should tar and feather the adults in the schools who are counting the days to retirement instead of helping our students learn to count.
Add Comment
You must Login to comment.

Click here to get an account it's free and quick