Tunneling, not trenching being used for water line

2012-02-03T00:30:00Z 2013-12-12T14:25:21Z Tunneling, not trenching being used for water lineCHANTAL M. LOVELL Napa Valley Register
February 03, 2012 12:30 am  • 

If Highway 221 is part of your commute, you may be fearing for the worst.

The west side of the highway, stretching for more than a mile from Napa Valley College south to Kaiser Road is lined with 24-inch wide segments of water pipe waiting to be placed underground.

But to the surprise and relief of many, this project may have no impact on drivers or adjacent properties.

Since mid-January, crews have been working to replace a 7,400-foot stretch of pipe using a technique known as directional drilling. Unlike traditional pipe-replacement methods, it does not require a wide trench to be dug.

Instead, a horizontal hole is made from an above-ground point, flushed with mud and drilling fluid and then filled with a semi-flexible piece of fusible polyvinyl chloride (PVC) pipe. The new pipe will be laid 40 feet below ground at its deepest point to avoid utilities and other barriers.

“Imagine a needle going through a piece of fabric,” said Megan Thomas, a city engineer. “The ground is the fabric.”

The technique is far less invasive than trench-digging, Thomas said. Had traditional pipe-replacement methods been used, all the trees in front of Napa Valley Memorial Park would have been removed, along with landscaping and signs in around Napa Valley College and the municipal golf course at Kennedy Park.

Additionally, a lane on south-bound Highway 221 would likely have been closed for the space required to dig a 12-foot-wide trench, Thomas said.

“You don’t have excavators and equipment going through (the area),” said Rob Craw, regional manager of Underground Solutions, the company behind the fusible pipe used in the project. “It eliminates excavation and restoration costs.”

While two crews drill space for the pipe, a third fuses long pieces of PVC pipe together. 

“There are no gaskets,” Craw said. “The weak point of a segmented pipe are the joints.”

In 2011, the city saw four major water lines break, all at the joints or collars that connect one segment of pipe to another. Water General Manager Joy Eldredge said because the PVC pipes are fused together using precise temperatures and measurements from a computer, there is far less room for error than with concrete pipes bound together using a crew and a backhoe.

“It’s like a computer versus us doing math,” she said.

In November, the City Council awarded a $3.1 million contract to HDD Company, Inc., of Cameron Park, to do the work. 

Thomas said it’s hard to quantify how much the project would have cost using traditional methods, but directional drilling certainly is the cheaper method because it does not require buying easements and unexpected costs are far less likely to arise.

“We look at this as what we’re not affecting,” she said. 

The new pipe will replace a 16-inch wide segment of pipe that currently restricts water flow between two 24-inch pipes, Eldredge said. According to the construction contract, the new pipe should be finished by May, before the summer increase in water demand.

The old pipe will be filled with concrete to prevent sinkholes and left in the ground, Eldredge said.

The city tried out the method on two smaller projects, one in 2008 and another in 2010, Thomas said. In some cases where there are narrow easements, utilities, trees and varied topography, directional drilling can replace traditional replacement methods in Napa.

“It’s definitely a technology that’s getting a lot of momentum,” Eldredge said.

Fusible PVC also holds promise because Napa soils are known to be particularly corrosive to concrete and cast-iron pipes. The PVC has a life expectancy of 50 to 100 years, officials said.

“The true data will be in about 70 to 80 years,” Eldredge said. Seeing the corrosion issues we see, it sure leads us to believe this is the right direction to go.”

Copyright 2015 Napa Valley Register. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

(8) Comments

  1. kevin
    Report Abuse
    kevin - February 03, 2012 5:15 am
    "fusable PVC"?

    Looks like HDPE (high density polyethylene) to me...
  2. babybirds
    Report Abuse
    babybirds - February 03, 2012 6:48 am
    This article is full of admiration for the technique of doing this job; but what is the water for and where is it going to and coming from? Does this mean more water for Napa County housing?
  3. Cookie
    Report Abuse
    Cookie - February 03, 2012 7:44 am
    This is great forthought considering we are in a very bad drought. I hope we can see more of these recycled water lines thoughout the county. Thank You to whoever is making this happen.
  4. REPUBLICANKID
    Report Abuse
    REPUBLICANKID - February 03, 2012 2:41 pm
    If it is not trated waste water It's from the new Storage plant off HWY 12
  5. Rocket
    Report Abuse
    Rocket - February 03, 2012 2:43 pm
    It is a potable drinking water line, coming from Jamieson water treatment plant. Not reclaim water..... And not for Napa pipe yet.
  6. Joe B
    Report Abuse
    Joe B - February 03, 2012 5:56 pm
    How about a diagram of the old vs new location? Napa Pipe, makes you wonder when you see pipe off loaded in the parking lot at the boat launch of Kennedy Park? 3.1 mil for less than a mile and a half? I thought that old transite main off Foster Rd was the main that's been blowing out? I guess a couple more $100 grand blow outs before that main gets replaced?
  7. 538orc
    Report Abuse
    538orc - February 04, 2012 3:28 am
    Joe B wrote "
    I thought that old transite main off Foster Rd was the main that's been blowing out? I guess a couple more $100 grand blow outs before that main gets replaced?

    Are you sure it is "transite". Old transite contained asbestos.
  8. Rocket
    Report Abuse
    Rocket - February 04, 2012 9:26 am
    there is a old existing main on the westside of town ( Foster rd. )A old existing main on the eastside of town (Hwy 221) the existing main on the eastside of town is a lot smaller than the one on foster rd. This new 24" main will help balance the system. help preventing the 36" main on Foster rd. from blowing. Yes it is AC pipe Abestos Concrete, miles of it around town, perfectly safe
Add Comment
You must Login to comment.

Click here to get an account it's free and quick