Why Claiming Social Security Is Really Just a Gamble

Why Claiming Social Security Is Really Just a Gamble

  • 0
Why Claiming Social Security Is Really Just a Gamble

One of the most difficult retirement decisions you'll have to make is choosing when to file for Social Security. Though your benefits are calculated based on your lifetime earnings, you're not entitled to your full monthly benefit until you reach full retirement age, or FRA. Here's what FRA looks like, depending on when you were born:

Year of Birth

Full Retirement Age




66 and 2 months


66 and 4 months


66 and 6 months


66 and 8 months


66 and 10 months

1960 or later



That said, you're allowed to sign up for Social Security as early as age 62, but for each month you claim benefits ahead of FRA, they'll be reduced by a certain percentage. And on the flipside, you can also delay benefits past FRA, boosting them by 8% a year in the process up until you turn 70, at which point that incentive expires.

Clearly, there are consequences to claiming benefits at different ages, though interestingly enough, if you live an average lifespan, there really shouldn't be. That's because in that situation, Social Security is technically designed to pay you the same lifetime total regardless of when you initially file.

Here's how that's possible: When you file for benefits ahead of FRA, you get less money each month, but you also get a larger number of individual payments so that if you live an average lifespan, it all works out. And the reverse holds true as well. Delaying your benefits will give you more money on a monthly basis, but fewer individual payments to collect.


But here's when that break-even formula doesn't apply: when you're likely to pass away at a young age or outlive the typical senior. And that's why, to a large extent, filing for Social Security is really nothing more than one giant gamble.

Can you predict the future?

As a general rule, if you expect to pass away on the young side, you'd be wise to claim Social Security early to collect the maximum amount of money in your lifetime. And if you expect to live a long life, delaying your benefits as long as possible makes financial sense.

Case in point: If you're entitled to a monthly benefit of $1,500 at an FRA of 67, and you file at 62, you'll shrink each payment you collect to $1,050, but you'll collect 60 more individual payments. If you pass away at age 73, which is relatively young (over a decade earlier than average life expectancy for today's 65-year-olds), you'll end up with more than $30,000 extra in lifetime Social Security income by filing at 62 rather than waiting until FRA.

Now, let's take that same $1,500 benefit but assume you delay your filing until age 70. Doing so will give you $1,860 a month, but with 36 fewer lifetime payments. If you live until 90, which is about half a decade longer than the typical senior is expected to, you'll come out over $32,000 ahead by delaying benefits instead of claiming them at 67.

Based on all of this, you'd think the formula for deciding when to claim benefits would be simple: If your health is poor, file early. If your health is great, file as late as possible.

The problem, however, is that none of us can predict the future. You might enter retirement in bad health but make lifestyle changes that lead to a much-improved outlook a few years down the line. Or, science might come up with a treatment or cure for the disease that's supposedly cutting your life expectancy short.

The same holds true if your health is great and you have a strong family history of longevity. You could suddenly get diagnosed with a disease that you're the first in your family to get, thereby causing you to pass away much sooner than any doctor would've predicted prior to that diagnosis.

As such, claiming Social Security really is, to a large degree, a gamble, since you don't know how long you're going to live. And since that's the case, often, the best you can do is make an educated guess based on your health, and life's other circumstances as well. For example, if you're low on savings going into retirement and have no reason to believe you won't live a long life, then delaying benefits makes a lot of sense. Or, if you're laid off from your job in your early 60s and don't manage to find another one, claiming benefits early is smart if you need them to pay the bills.

What's the right call?

When it comes to signing up for Social Security, there's really no right or wrong answer. The best you can do, therefore, is make sure your health is a major factor -- but by no means the only factor -- in your decision.

The $16,728 Social Security bonus most retirees completely overlook

If you're like most Americans, you're a few years (or more) behind on your retirement savings. But a handful of little-known "Social Security secrets" could help ensure a boost in your retirement income. For example: one easy trick could pay you as much as $16,728 more... each year! Once you learn how to maximize your Social Security benefits, we think you could retire confidently with the peace of mind we're all after. Simply click here to discover how to learn more about these strategies.

The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.


The business news you need

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Related to this story

Most Popular


Chances are that if you have student loans, you need every bit of extra cash that you can get. Did you realize that your student loans might be able to generate some cash for you?

Under certain circumstances, you may be able to save on your tax bill by deducting the interest that you pay on your student loan. The total deduction from your taxable income could be as much as $2,500. As a final bonus, you do not have to itemize to claim this deduction.

To be eligible for the deduction, your loan must meet certain qualifications. It must have been made to cover qualified education expenses as defined in IRS Publication 970, including tuition, fees, and most room and board charges. The loan cannot have come from a relative or via a qualified employer plan, and the e...

9 Crucial Tax Deductions

Your Unpaid Student Loan Could Cost You Your Tax Refund

Only 25% Of Americans Know This Simple Tax-Savings Trick

  • Updated


Thanks to the Affordable Care Act (ACA), you should receive 1095 forms along with the W-2, 1099, and other tax forms that you receive from employers and financial institutions. The 1095 forms verify your health care insurance status for tax purposes. 1095-A forms debuted in 2015, while taxpayers received 1095-B or 1095-C forms for the first time in 2016.

All You Need to Know About the ObamaCare Tax Forms

Form 1095-A is issued through the Federal Health Insurance Marketplace for those who purchased health insurance through the marketplace. Effectively, it is your proof of insurance if you are receiving insurance outside of an employer. All consumers who received cost assistance through the marketplace need the 1095-A form to be able to file their taxes properly.

Forms 1095-B and 1095-C are complementary forms...

Tax Impact Of The Affordable Care Act

ObamaCare Savings

8 Of 9 Financially Vulnerable Americans Used Tax Refunds To Pay Bills


The IRS recommends that you keep tax records for at least three years from the date you filed your original return, and longer for special situations. You may need copies of your tax returns for tasks like filing future years' taxes, applying for a mortgage loan or student aid, or settling IRS inquiries.

How to Get Your Past Tax Returns

If you cannot find your old tax returns and need to order a tax return transcript from the IRS, you have several options. For the really old-school methods, you can call the IRS at 800-908-9946 and follow the prompts, or fill out IRS Form 4506-T or Form 4506T-EZ for an individual transcript and mail it to the address noted on the form. The IRS suggests that you submit mail requests thirty calendar days in advance of the need to make sure you don't miss the...

What Is My IRS Pin?

Getting The Jump On April 15

6 Tips For When An IRS Letter Arrives In The Mail

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.


News Alerts

Breaking News