A dispute over a planned, 475,000-gallon-a-year Benjamin Ranch winery with tours, tastings and marketing events in Napa Valley's Rutherford area may not be decided until next spring.
Rich and Leslie Frank of Frank Family Vineyards secured county Planning Commission approval in May to build Benjamin Ranch winery along Conn Creek Road near Highway 128. Vintner Michael Honig and Keep Rutherford Rural filed an appeal.
The Napa County Board of Supervisors was to decide the matter on Tuesday. But a county report said the parties have agreed to delay the hearing until March 8.
Attorney Scott Greenwood-Meinert made the case to the Planning Commission on May 19 why the winery of this size should be allowed. He said the valley needs more wine production capacity.
“Napa Valley needs more projects like this one, where large vineyard areas have a large vineyard management yard that can easily be converted to a serious production facility with minimal vineyard loss,” he said.
People are also reading…
The appeal by Honig/Save Rural Rutherford said an environmental impact report is required to address the project’s possible impacts. It mentioned such areas as traffic, traffic safety, greenhouse gas, noise, water supply and flood hazards.
“The county has also relied on an incomplete and misleading comparison of the project to other wineries in Napa Valley, improperly downsizing the oversized nature of the project,” the appeal said.
The local group Napa Vision 2050 in a recent newsletter stated its opposition to the project, with its approval to have up to 87,150 guests annually.
“Do we want, in our rural valley, ‘Disneyland’ size and style tourist attractions?” the group asked.
Rich Frank responded to a similar comment during a September 2020 Planning Commission hearing. He is former president of Paramount Television Group and Disney Studios and is vice president of the American Film Institute board of directors. The Franks run Frank Family Vineyards winery on Larkmead Lane near Calistoga.
“We are not looking to pave paradise ... and we’re not looking to build Disneyland,” he said.
A county report responded to 21 grounds for appeal by Honig/Save Rural Rutherford. It recommended that the Board of Supervisors deny the appeal and uphold the Planning Commission decision.
Honig runs Honig Vineyard and Winery near the Benjamin Ranch.
Benjamin Ranch winery would be located on 87 acres along Conn Creek Road at Highway 128. The Planning Commission approved the project by a 3-2 vote on May 19.
“The growers in our community would not survive if it was not for facilities that could handle their production,” Commissioner Dave Whitmer said.
He and Commissioners Andrew Mazotti and Megan Dameron voted to approve Benjamin Ranch winery.
The requested 475,000 gallons in production is large in the middle of the agricultural preserve, Commissioner Joelle Gallagher said.
“I think bringing in fruit from all over to this particular spot is going to be a real pressure on the traffic in an area that is already really unmanageable,” she said.
Gallagher and Commissioner Anne Cottrell voted against the project as proposed. Cottrell called the 87 acres a prime location for a winery on the valley floor, but she too had traffic concerns.
Catch up on Napa County's top news stories
In case you missed it, here is a look at the most-read stories on NapaValleyRegister.com.
Get unlimited digital access to the Napa Valley Register for just $1 for your first 6 months! Enjoy every article without restrictions and find tons of subscriber-only perks, such as access to our daily eEdition. Click here for details!
Three Californians explain why they decided to leave the Golden State and move to Arkansas — and what they found there.
Napa Valley has lured many young winemakers from across the globe. But in the case of Laura Díaz Muñoz the trip to Napa was meant only to be a…
Noel Bito wants to "bring back the old-school barber" with his Midtown Barbershop, opening soon at 1080 Main St., Suite C, in St. Helena.
A new California law requires residents and businesses to separate organic materials, like bananas peels, from regular trash and recycling.
The City of Calistoga is preparing to make a new offer to the County of Napa to purchase the entire Napa County Fairgrounds property, includin…
In a valley with over 500 wineries and countless others across the country and globe, it is getting harder and harder for independent winemake…
A tapeworm invaded this Napan's brain in 2015. How's he doing today?
The Napa Valley Vintners recently rolled out their new Collective Napa Valley, inviting locals as well as global wine enthusiasts to join a ye…
Cyclists are using a newly widened sidewalk that fills a Napa Valley Vine Trail gap along Soscol Avenue.
You can reach Barry Eberling at 256-2253 or email@example.com.