You are the owner of this article.
McVicar Vineyards & Winery, once the site of Dahl Vineyards, sells for $5.5 million
Wine Industry

McVicar Vineyards & Winery, once the site of Dahl Vineyards, sells for $5.5 million

From the Napa Valley Wine Insider Digest: Dec. 20, 2019 series

The McVicar Vineyards & Winery property on Solano Avenue, once the site of Robert Dahl Vineyards, has been sold, listing agent Cyd Greer confirmed.

The sale closed in late November, Greer said. The Yountville property was purchased by the Hill family of Hill Family Estate for $5.5 million, about half a million dollars under its initial listing price of $5.96 million.

The property found itself in the national spotlight in 2015 after former tenant Robert Dahl committed a murder-suicide nearby. The winery’s previous owners, the McVicar family, constructed a 1,131-square-foot winery with permits to produce 20,000 gallons a year in the late 1980s.

The winery, named Chateau Chais de Napa, had no marketing or visitation allowances. It became largely dormant in the mid-2000s, according to The Napa Wine Project. The space sat vacant until Dahl, an entrepreneur with a checkered past, leased it from three sisters in the McVicar family in 2014.

Dahl’s name was splashed across headlines in 2015 after he shot and killed Emad Tawfilis, an investor in Dahl Vineyards, before ultimately taking his own life. Tawfilis, claiming fraud, had come to the winery to reclaim a $1.2 million loan he’d made to Dahl.

In late 2016, the Napa County Planning Commission amended the winery’s use permit, including allowance of up to 84 visitors per week and 10 marketing events annually with up to 30 guests each. Planning Commissioner Jeri Gill then called the amendments “a modest project”.

It went on the market at the end of 2018. Greer became its listing agent in late June of this year, she said.

“There was a lot of interest right out of the gate,” Greer added.

Greer, describing the property as largely “turnkey,” said she believes the Hills will use the property’s visitation entitlement. She noted that the property also has an outdoor crushpad and an elevated patio area for tastings.

Hill Family Estate, whose Yountville winery is operated by father-son pair Doug and Ryan Hill, began producing wine in 2001, according to the winery’s website. Hill Family owns vineyards in north Napa, Carneros, Atlas Peak and the Oak Knoll District, along with a handful outside of the Napa appellation, the website says. Their family-owned winery also operates a tasting room in Yountville.

Hill Family Estate declined comment, citing the recent nature of the deal.

The property’s estate vineyards include 3.85 acres planted to Cabernet Sauvignon, almost 2 acres planted to Merlot and a small planting of Cabernet Franc. Some of the vines were planted shortly after the winery was built in 1992, Greer said, and other plantings are as recent as 2015.

“I felt the buyer was a perfect fit for the property,” Greer said of Hill Family Estate. “I was happy to see it was a local family who purchased the land. They have an existing business, and this allows them the take the next step.”

Sarah Klearman's top five most memorable stories from 2019

2019 marked my arrival at the Register and subsequent dive into Napa's wine industry. The year has also been host to excellent coverage of community news by my colleagues. Here are my top 5. 

You can reach Sarah Klearman at (707) 256-2213 or

Get local news delivered to your inbox!

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Wine Industry Reporter

Wine industry reporter at the Napa Valley Register.

Related to this story

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.


News Alerts

Breaking News