Skip to main contentSkip to main content
You have permission to edit this article.

What are They doing to our sense of place?

  • Updated

There’s a deep sadness when we lose a friend. We miss the familiarity and good times we’ve spent together over many years. Similarly, there’s a profound sadness when you no longer recognize what had been your home and your community. You no longer recognize it because it is being taken away from you piece by piece.

Gone are the toy shop, the dance studio, downtown Safeway, Pearl, Cervoni, Zeller, Brewsters -- places where you were welcomed, where you met friends, where your children met friends.

It’s all in the name of progress. They (our elected and appointed officials) tell us we need tourist revenue. But We (the people who live here) need our sense of place. We are losing the soul of our Napa.

And now, they have done it again. After almost weekly announcements of the demise of yet another local establishment, They told the model railroad museum at Expo it had to close. This museum was built by our fathers and grandfathers and designed to represent our Napa. But They decided the space is needed for progress. And many residents of Napa are deeply sad; this is a location so many have enjoyed for generations.

Last year, Napa Vision 2050 sponsored a forum on the social and economic costs of tourism. The main message was that unless carefully managed, tourism can irrevocably destroy the essence of place. You have only to look at what has happened in Aspen and Santa Fe and now Barcelona and Venice. A noted book on this subject, “Devil’s Bargains,” (Rothman, 1998) notes that residents gradually realize, as they seek to preserve the authenticity of their community, that decision-making power has shifted from the community to the newly arrived corporate financiers.

The forum was well attended by county supervisors and city council members from the Napa Valley. We encouraged them to act on this message of responsible, countywide planning by collectively managing the growth path they have been fostering. Not one of them has done so. Instead they are in the counting houses drooling over the increasing Transient Occupancy Tax.

And now -- to add insult to injury -- They are taking away our community model railroad museum. Who would have predicted this move and the wrenching impact it is having on the hearts of many Napans?

NV2050 is holding a community town hall meeting this Thursday evening in Napa (and on Sept. 7 in St. Helena) to hear from you. How do you feel about these changes and what do you recommend we do to bring our community back under control?

Longtime Napan Harris Nussbaum will moderate the discussion at the Horseman’s Association, 1200 Foster Road at 7 p.m. Please attend. For details, visit

Dan Mufson, President

Napa Vision 2050

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Related to this story

Change your leaves, keep your roots intact.We live in a society where the pace of change accelerates every year, with new apps to download, ne…

I hope Expo's board of directors will speedily reconsider their ill-advised vote not to renew the Napa Valley Model Railroad Historical Societ…

So I see that another "affordable" spot (for the Napa Valley Model Train folks) has fallen so that a larger parking lot can be built to accomm…

Shame on the Napa Town & Country Fair board for closing down the Model Railroad Club's long-time venue -- and for what? A parking lot? Tha…

Another further tragic episode in Napa's history. The fair board has finally gotten its wish of not renewing the Model Railroad's lease after …

I was a teenage member of the Napa model railroad club in the mid-'70s. I learned important life lessons and practical skills that I still use today.

Napa Valley Register recently published two articles that announced the closing, due to rent increase, of two Napa Valley local-owned business…

What gives with the board of directors of the fair? Don't the people who call Napa their hometown get any consideration, or is it all about to…

We recently learned that the Napa Valley Model Railroad Historical Society will be displaced this December from their home at the fairgrounds.

I thoroughly enjoy living in Napa, home for many years, enjoying small-time values and being able to afford a splurge every now and then.

While this may be a little after the fact, I feel compelled to share that on July 25, I had the distinct displeasure of attending the Napa Val…

Vision 2050 held a town hall meeting recently in Napa to discuss the need to protect Napa Valley's families, public health, and habitat. I was…

Listen now and subscribe: Apple Podcasts | Google Podcasts | Spotify | Stitcher | RSS Feed | Omny Studio

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.


News Alerts

Breaking News